Mama Lil’s PeppaLilli Mustard Pickle Relish $11.95

Every summer, Howard Lev’s mother, Lil, planted a crop of Hungarian Goathorn peppers at their Youngstown, Ohio, home.​

​Come harvest, she’d pickle and marinate them in a vibrant mixture of oils and aromatic spices based on a recipe given to her by a Serbian friend. They were the family’s ubiquitous condiment, a jar of the sweet-and-spicy mix always at the center of the table. Later on, Lev’s frustration with being unable to find anything comparable eventually prompted him to launch Mama Lil’s, which sells his mother’s recipe. Unlike similar jarred peppers, which typically are picked and pickled when young and green or yellow, Lev uses peppers that have ripened to orange and red, allowing their natural sweetness to better balance their fiery kick.

Not sure how you’d use it?

We test everything we sell. Here’s how we’d use this.


Pile it high on hot dogs, sausages and sandwiches of all kinds. Serve on a cheeseboard alongside a sharp aged cheddar and perhaps some pretzels. Try it as a dip for appetizers or a flavor boost for dressings for salad and slaw. A dollop of the stuff on baked beans brightens up the dish immediately. And using it in place of the Branston pickles on a classic British country ploughman’s lunch plate adds an extra dose of complexity.

Free Shipping

On purchases of $125+ in the contiguous 48 states.

Bulk Savings

Save up to 40% on items when you purchase 2 or more!