Good caramel is hard to do well—it’s quite literally a science—so it makes sense that the genius behind McCrea’s Candies has a background in chemistry. And his research really pays off: McCrea’s caramels are some of the best we’ve tried. Their Single Malt Scotch flavor combines malty alcohol, with hints of smoky vanilla, with their signature dark, toasty caramel recipe for a smooth pairing that doesn’t taste boozy. But it’s really the distinct texture that brings these treats to the next level. Soft with a slight bite, this caramel won’t stick to your teeth, it only melts in your mouth. Each box comes loaded with about 20 caramels, but don’t be fooled—these addictive candies will disappear fast.

Good caramel is hard to do well—it’s quite literally a science—so it makes sense that the genius behind McCrea’s Candies has a background in chemistry. And his research really pays off: McCrea’s caramels are some of the best we’ve tried. Their Black Lava Sea Salt is a fun twist on traditional salted caramel, which balances sweet, dark, toasty caramel and small flecks of black sea salt expertly. And unlike other salted caramels, the punch of salt in this version doesn’t disappear into overly sweet caramel. But it’s really the distinct texture that brings these treats to the next level. Soft with a slight bite, this caramel won’t stick to your teeth, it only melts in your mouth. And the salt adds a light, pleasant crunch, too. Each box comes loaded with about 20 caramels, but don’t be fooled—these addictive candies will disappear fast.

Good caramel is hard to do well—it’s quite literally a science—so it makes sense that the genius behind McCrea’s Candies has a background in chemistry. And his research really pays off: McCrea’s caramels are some of the best we’ve tried. Their Tapped Maple flavor combines the earthy, nearly burnt goodness of maple with their signature dark, toasty caramel recipe for a cohesive pairing that doesn’t taste cloyingly sweet. But it’s really the distinct texture that brings these treats to the next level. Soft with a slight bite, this caramel won’t stick to your teeth, it only melts in your mouth. Each box comes loaded with about 20 caramels, but don’t be fooled—these addictive candies will disappear fast.